Winx Club RE-DO?

Subject: Winx Club RE-DO? Mon Nov 03, 2014 12:34 am

First topic message reminder :

I really think the Winx Club series needs to be re-dubbed in English 100%, just like Sailor Moon is doing, Viz Media took those rights and is going to go through all the movies, and episodes and specials with an all new cast, never dropping or replacing anyone!

I think Viz Media or another company should do the same for the Winx Club because come on the Winx have been through a LOT. Their European English dub is terrible and the old 90s version could use some work, Nick was the one that had the good version and now that's done for nowadays.

What do you think? To me I just find it annoying that you have to watch this series in different actor voices every other season its pure ignorant.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Mon Nov 03, 2014 12:50 pm

newhere16 wrote:

TheWonderer wrote:: Of course everyone will think the original English dub was bad because they grew up on the 4kids one...The original one is always the best! Nick and the original since nick did match the original version. The 4kids one had way to many flaws and if that was the "best dub" then it would have way more than 3 seasons. But I doubt winx club will ever be picked up again due to it being in it's last leg.

No, I don't mean 4Kids is the best because of that. Like I said, only the voice actresses and actors they picked fitted the characters pretty well.

Musa and Layla's voices where terrible Sad

I think they never got a good match of Aisha really.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Mon Nov 03, 2014 2:49 pm

TheWonderer wrote:

newhere16 wrote:

TheWonderer wrote:: Of course everyone will think the original English dub was bad because they grew up on the 4kids one...The original one is always the best! Nick and the original since nick did match the original version. The 4kids one had way to many flaws and if that was the "best dub" then it would have way more than 3 seasons. But I doubt winx club will ever be picked up again due to it being in it's last leg.

No, I don't mean 4Kids is the best because of that. Like I said, only the voice actresses and actors they picked fitted the characters pretty well.

Musa and Layla's voices where terrible Sad

I think they never got a good match of Aisha really.

I loved Musa's voice the most, it just fit her tomboyish personality pretty well. Although Aisha's freaked me out a bit, it was kind of manly. I'm sure they intended that but I'll admit the only thing I like about Rai is the voice they gave Aisha.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Mon Nov 03, 2014 7:08 pm

Tbh, I think Nick's voices were the best (Except for Stella. I think Rai did a better job with Stella).

4Kidz voices were okay for Bloom and Stella but the others annoyed me.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Tue Nov 04, 2014 7:22 am

How do you know that the Winx will be over with come S7? I think it may continue onward after that perhaps? And I still think the Winx should do the whole over-do thing I think it would suit the series best.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Tue Nov 04, 2014 8:14 am

TheWonderer wrote:: Of course everyone will think the original English dub was bad because they grew up on the 4kids one...The original one is always the best! Nick and the original since nick did match the original version. The 4kids one had way to many flaws and if that was the "best dub" then it would have way more than 3 seasons. But I doubt winx club will ever be picked up again due to it being in it's last leg.
.

your arguments about fans growing up with the 4kids dubb liking it the best isn't true. I grew up with the 4kids dub of winx aswell as other shows like yugioh and one price and i don't like any of the 4kids dub. The only one i found somewhat good was the Pokemon dub as that show can be over the top and cheesy all it wants and the dub would still fit. I honestly like rai the best but the nick voice actors are my prefered choice, if we get a rai dub with good actors who sound distinct and not the same we would have a perfect dubb

RP Moderator Posts : 9973

4kids has a knack for cutting out things and making the story line a bit more confusing. Like Yugioh, they cut out Yugi's mom from the only ep she was in.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Tue Nov 04, 2014 10:54 am

My favorite dub was the Rai English,it was so much better and realistic than 4kids, Nick's is fine, I like some of the voices like Stella and Musa but Rai English will always be the best one in my opinion.

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Sat Nov 08, 2014 11:44 pm

Pokémon Trainer wrote:

TheWonderer wrote:: Of course everyone will think the original English dub was bad because they grew up on the 4kids one...The original one is always the best! Nick and the original since nick did match the original version. The 4kids one had way to many flaws and if that was the "best dub" then it would have way more than 3 seasons. But I doubt winx club will ever be picked up again due to it being in it's last leg.
.

your arguments about fans growing up with the 4kids dubb liking it the best isn't true. I grew up with the 4kids dub of winx aswell as other shows like yugioh and one price and i don't like any of the 4kids dub. The only one i found somewhat good was the Pokemon dub as that show can be over the top and cheesy all it wants and the dub would still fit. I honestly like rai the best but the nick voice actors are my prefered choice, if we get a rai dub with good actors who sound distinct and not the same we would have a perfect dubb

Ah I guess your right it's just in my years of being in this fandom a lot of people wavired over towards the 4kids dub. What if they did a dub with the movie voices?

Subject: Re: Winx Club RE-DO? Sat Nov 08, 2014 11:52 pm

zerowing21 wrote:: 4kids has a knack for cutting out things and making the story line a bit more confusing. Like Yugioh, they cut out Yugi's mom from the only ep she was in.

don't even get me started on what they did to yugioh. Clearly an anime adaptation of a manga which was rated T (16+) even in the duel monsters arcs should be targeted at little children so we must make all the characters dumb and stupid and remove any charecter development from some of the best charecters in the show cough katsuya cough i could go on about yugioh but this is a winx topic so i better change the subject before i ramble on too much

about the movie voices... I don't mind them but bloom voice actor is waaaaay to high pitched, she sounds like a 5 year old child not a 20 year old. The rest of them are pretty fine its just blooms which is annoying and sweaky. They should really think about getting voice actors who match the charecter designs. It'll really help allot like allot. The nick voices matched the characters perfectly ecept Stella which could of been less sqeuaky but meh. cant we just get the voice actors from nick to leave nick and still voice them for season 7 xD if arianna Grande can leave for a music career why cant they? ok maybe in being silly but its late and might and im tired. Sorry for rambling xD

Winx Fairy Posts : 12 Age : 31 Location : Madera, CA, USA

OK after quickly skimming through this topic I have an opinion and this comes from the fact that I worked with many blind people growing up. If a person can't see to figure out who a person is in the real world, they more likely than not will use the person's voice to identify the person. Now, how does it make sense if you look at it from that perspective to keep changing the voice actors for a cartoon show, especially one that has been running for at least 3 seasons? I mean if a person relies on the sound of a voice to identify and connect with a person in the real world, shouldn't the same logic apply when connecting with a cartoon character? If anything having consistent voice actors makes the characters just that more "believable" if you know what I mean. I honestly can't tell the difference but some of the employees at work can especially those with limited or now eyesight.

» Winx Club In Australia! Nine Network picks up Winx Club Series and Specials!
» Winx Club Third Film?..."Winx Club:The Next Big Adventure"
» Winx Club: We Are The Magical Winx, Way Of Sirenix, & Living The Magic Lyric Videos
» Winx Club Online is back! + Winx Adventure Social Game!
» The Winx Club Next Generation Season 4 Episode 3 Winx on Earth